Rowing With Bad Knees: Is the Erg a Good Idea?
Usually yes — and often it is the best cardio option available to you. But "rowing is low impact" is a half-truth that sends a lot of people with sore knees onto a machine set up in a way that makes them sorer. The impact is genuinely near-zero. The range of motion is not, and that is what knees object to.
This is general information rather than medical advice. If you have a diagnosed knee condition, a recent injury or a replacement, ask the physiotherapist or surgeon who knows your knee before starting.
Why rowing is usually kind to knees
Running loads the knee with several times bodyweight on every footfall, repeated thousands of times a session.[1] Rowing has no footfall at all: your feet stay strapped to the footplates and the load is applied smoothly through a pushing motion against resistance you choose. There is no landing, no jarring and no eccentric braking — the three things that make running hard on a damaged joint.
The leg drive is also a closed-chain movement, which tends to be better tolerated than open-chain leg extensions by knees with patellofemoral problems. And because the resistance scales with how hard you pull, a gentle row genuinely is gentle in a way that a slow run is not.
The part that actually causes trouble
At the catch — the front of the stroke — your knees are deeply flexed, often past 120 degrees. Deep flexion under load is precisely the position that irritates patellofemoral pain, meniscal issues and arthritic knees. The stroke then asks you to drive out of that position forcefully.
So the problem is not impact. It is how far you compress, how hard you load it there, and how many times. All three are adjustable, which is why most people with cranky knees can row comfortably once the machine is set up properly.
Five adjustments, in order of how much they help
1. Shorten the stroke. You do not have to come all the way to the catch. Stop where your shins reach vertical — or earlier — and drive from there. You lose a little stroke length and almost no training effect, and it takes the knee out of its most provocative range entirely. This single change fixes most cases.
2. Raise your feet. Move the footplates up a notch or two. A higher foot position reduces the depth of knee flexion at the catch directly, and most machines allow several settings. Counter-intuitively, higher feet means less compression, not more.
3. Drop the damper. Set it to 3–4, not 8–10. High damper means more force required at the catch, which is exactly where the knee is most vulnerable. It does not make you stronger, it just changes the gearing — see drag factor explained and damper vs resistance.
4. Slow the recovery. Rushing up the slide means arriving at the catch with momentum and absorbing it through the knees. The recovery should take about twice as long as the drive. Our common mistakes guide covers rushing the slide, which is the single most common fault in self-taught rowers.
5. Keep your knees tracking over your feet. Knees falling inward or splaying outward at the catch concentrates load on one side of the joint. This is usually a hip mobility issue rather than a knee one, and it is worth watching for in a mirror.
Our full knee pain troubleshooting guide goes through the diagnostic order in more detail, including what to do if the pain is behind the kneecap versus along the joint line.
Which machine, if you're still choosing
Three specifications matter more than the usual ones:
Seat height. A 14-inch seat means a deep squat to get on and off, before you've rowed a stroke. Higher-seat machines — the Concept2 Model E sits at 20 inches, and several others are in that range — make the whole thing easier on a knee that dislikes deep flexion. The higher-seat machines we recommend are chosen largely on this.
Adjustable footplates. Non-negotiable, and most machines have them. Fixed footplates remove your most useful adjustment.
Smooth, progressive resistance. Air and magnetic machines load smoothly. Hydraulic machines can feel notchy at the start of the drive, which is a sharper loading pattern than a sore knee wants. Our comparison of air vs water vs magnetic covers how each feels at the catch.
How to start
Ten minutes, easy, with a shortened stroke. Then stop — even if it feels fine. Knee symptoms frequently arrive the day after rather than during, so the first week is about finding your tolerance rather than training. If ten minutes produces nothing the next day, go to fifteen. Build the duration before you touch the intensity, and keep the whole first month in the easy zone.
Warm up properly, which matters more with an irritable joint than a healthy one: five minutes of very light paddling before anything else. Our warm-up and cool-down guide has a sequence that takes no longer than it needs to.
When to stop and see someone
Rowing through a knee that is swelling, locking, giving way, or producing sharp rather than dull pain is not a plan. Nor is rowing through pain that is getting steadily worse week on week despite the adjustments above. Any of those is a reason to stop and get it looked at — the erg will still be there afterwards, and a knee seen early is usually a smaller problem than a knee seen in March.
If rowing turns out not to suit your knee at all, that is useful information rather than a failure, and there are alternatives worth trying. Our rowing vs running comparison covers the trade-offs between the common options.
References
- Comparison of ground reaction forces as running speed increases - Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology
- What Damper Setting and Drag Factor to Use on the Concept2 RowErg - Concept2
- Indoor Rowing Technique on the Concept2 RowErg - Concept2
Frequently asked questions
- Is a rowing machine bad for your knees?
- Not usually - there is no impact at all, which makes it gentler than running or most court sports. The issue is range of motion: the catch puts the knee in deep flexion under load, which is adjustable by shortening the stroke and raising the footplates.
- How do I row without hurting my knees?
- Shorten the stroke so you stop before deep compression, raise your feet in the footplates, drop the damper to 3-4, slow the recovery down, and keep your knees tracking over your feet. The first two fix most cases on their own.
- Is rowing or cycling better for bad knees?
- Both are low impact. Cycling keeps the knee in a smaller, more controlled range, which suits a knee that dislikes deep flexion; rowing works far more of the body. If deep flexion is your limit, a shortened rowing stroke gets you most of the way to both.

Jordan Lockwood (BSc, CPT)
Certified personal trainer (CPT), sports-science graduate, and lifelong rower. Jordan writes and reviews every guide on Rowing Machine Nerd.