Rowing Machine Reviews

Honest, research-based reviews scored on a consistent methodology - no paid placements, no marketing copy. Just what you need to know before you buy.

Every machine is scored across six weighted dimensions - see how we rate.

Buying Guide

Air vs. Water vs. Magnetic Rowing Machines: Which Type?

Start here before you buy. How the three resistance types compare on feel, noise, data, and price - and which one is right for your space and goals.

Read Article

Air rower

Concept2 Model D (RowErg) Review

The benchmark air rower: gold-standard data, near-indestructible build, and resale value that makes its price look like a bargain.

Read Article

Water rower

WaterRower Natural Review

A handcrafted ash water rower that's as much furniture as fitness - beautiful and quiet, with a smooth natural stroke, but a basic monitor for the money.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5623 Review

A budget dual-resistance rower that folds away and undercuts almost everything - fine for light home use, but the basic monitor and modest build show the price.

Read Article

Water rower

WaterRower GX Review

A durable studio-oriented water rower with smooth resistance, but a bare-bones monitor and no connectivity now that it's discontinued.

Read Article

Water rower

First Degree Monaco Challenge AR Review

A commercial-grade adjustable water rower with a smooth, quiet stroke, held back by dated connectivity and a price that bumps into Concept2 territory.

Read Article

Air rower

Concept2 Model E Review

The Concept2 Model E pairs the brand's gold-standard air rowing with a raised 20-inch seat, at a premium over the standard RowErg.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

BodyCraft VR500 Pro Review

A well-built air-plus-magnetic rower with 32 electronic levels and a strong warranty, but priced well above the Concept2 benchmark.

Read Article

Water rower

WaterRower Club Review

A commercial-grade solid-ash water rower with authentic feel and BLE connectivity, held back by a dated S4 console and premium price.

Read Article

Water rower

WaterRower S1 Review

A stainless steel WaterRower with smooth water resistance and elite build, but a basic S4 monitor and high price temper the value.

Read Article

Air rower

Assault AirRower Elite Review

A rugged, commercial-grade air rower with a comfortable seat and smooth feel, held back by a basic console and a price above the Concept2 RowErg.

Read Article

Smart/connected rower

Hydrow Wave Review

A compact connected rower with smooth electromagnetic resistance and a polished 16-inch class experience, best for subscribers.

Read Article

Water rower

Ergatta Rower Review

A handsome water rower built around a gamified touchscreen platform, delivering engaging workouts at a premium hardware-plus-subscription price.

Read Article

Smart/connected rower

Hydrow Rower Review

A premium connected rower with a 22-inch screen and silent electromagnetic resistance, strong on content but reliant on an ongoing subscription.

Read Article

Smart/connected rower

Peloton Row Review

A premium connected rower with a swiveling HD touchscreen and real-time form coaching, held back by a high price and required membership.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

Life Fitness Heat Row Review

A commercial-grade hybrid air-magnetic rower with excellent build and comfort, but a steep price and limited connectivity on the base model.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

BodyCraft VR200 Review

A compact, foldable air-and-magnetic rower with solid build and simple metrics, but a basic monitor and ~$999 price put it against stronger rivals.

Read Article

Water rower

WaterRower A1 Home Review

A handsome, smooth-rowing entry WaterRower whose appeal is real but undercut by a bare-bones, app-less A1 monitor at a premium price.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

BodyCraft VR400 Pro Review

A sturdy, quiet air-magnetic rower with a strong warranty, held back by manual resistance, limited connectivity and a premium price.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

XTERRA Fitness ERG700 Review

A feature-rich air-plus-magnetic home rower with a high weight capacity, held back by a price that drifts into Concept2 territory.

Read Article

Water rower

Xterra ERG650W Review

A well-built water rower with a 5.5" LCD, six water levels and BLE/FTMS app support, positioned as a value alternative to premium water machines.

Read Article

Air rower

Xebex Air Rower Review

A sturdy, heavy-duty air rower with a 500 lb capacity and solid metrics, though its proprietary console limits cross-machine comparisons.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

SOLE Fitness SR500 Review

A foldable air-and-magnetic home rower with handle-mounted resistance control, a high weight capacity and lifetime frame warranty, but a basic LCD console.

Read Article

Smart/connected rower

Echelon Smart Row (Row-S) Review

A quiet, foldable magnetic rower with a 22-inch touchscreen and app classes, best suited to subscription-minded home users rather than performance rowers.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Teeter Power10 Elliptical Rower Review

A hybrid rower-elliptical with patented bi-directional resistance; great for low-impact full-body cardio, less so for true rowing technique.

Read Article

Hydraulic rower

Kettler Kadett Outrigger Review

A well-built hydraulic rower with a unique outrigger feathering action, but dated metrics and high pricing limit its appeal versus modern rivals.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

NordicTrack RW200 Review

A quiet, foldable air-plus-magnetic rower from NordicTrack that suits beginners but lacks top-end resistance and a streaming console.

Read Article

Water rower

Stamina Wave 1450 Review

A foldable water rower with a smooth stroke and bundled audio coaching, but a basic monitor and short parts warranty temper its value near the $1,300 mark.

Read Article

Water rower

Merax Water Review

An affordable steel-framed water rower with a smooth pull and inclined tank, held back by a basic monitor, no app support and a short warranty.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Bladez Cascade Rower Review

A quiet magnetic folding rower with 17 programs and an included heart-rate strap, but limited by no app support and a short warranty.

Read Article

Water rower

Fitness Reality 3000WR Review

A budget-friendly water rower with a smooth stroke, a basic but informative monitor and app tracking, held back by short warranty coverage.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Fitness Reality 4000MR Review

A sturdy mid-budget magnetic rower whose dual oar-style handles deliver an unusual sculling motion, but it skips app connectivity and stays bulky when stored.

Read Article

Water rower

Sunny Phantom Hydro Water Rowing Machine (SF-RW5910) Review

A capable, affordable water rower with a genuine smooth stroke and sturdy frame, held back by a basic monitor and no app connectivity.

Read Article

Air rower

Stamina ATS Air Rower Review

A genuine but basic budget air rower: real wind resistance and easy storage, held back by plastic build, a 250 lb limit, and a no-frills monitor.

Read Article

Hydraulic rower

Stamina 1333 Precision Rower Review

A compact, affordable hydraulic rower suited to light, occasional workouts, but limited by piston fade, no connectivity, and a short rail.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

XTERRA Fitness ERG400 Review

A folding air-plus-magnetic budget rower with a 16-level console; capable and affordable, but reliability reports and a short parts warranty temper it.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

ProForm 440R Review

A compact, foldable magnetic rower for budget home gyms, with smooth resistance but a short rail, basic monitor and modest build.

Read Article

Air rower

Stamina X Air Rower Review

A budget-friendly foldable air rower with smooth resistance, but a basic monitor, modest seat and short parts warranty hold it back.

Read Article

Hydraulic rower

Kettler Favorit Review

A compact, budget hydraulic rower suited to short casual workouts, but resistance fades with use and there's no app connectivity.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

LifeSpan RW1000 Review

A quiet, foldable magnetic rower that's fine for beginners but feels overpriced at list and lacks the connectivity and rail length serious rowers want.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Echanfit Magnetic Rowing Machine (CRW 4901) Review

A quiet, foldable budget magnetic rower with 16 resistance levels and a 350 lb capacity, best suited to casual home cardio.

Read Article

Air rower

Stamina Air Rower Review

An affordable, foldable air rower that covers the basics for beginners but is held back by inconsistent resistance and ergonomic limits.

Read Article

Air rower

Xterra ERG500 Air Turbine Rower Review

An affordable air-turbine rower with a responsive feel and 300 lb capacity, held back by a basic monitor and no app connectivity.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Stamina 1130 Magnetic Rowing Machine Review

A compact, quiet budget magnetic rower with 16 resistance levels and a heart-rate strap, but no app connectivity and a short parts warranty.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

Sunny SF-RW5940 Magnetic Air Rower Review

A foldable budget rower pairing 16-level magnetic resistance with an air fan for a livelier pull, best for casual home use rather than serious training.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Sunny SF-RW5941 SMART Review

A quiet, foldable magnetic rower with app connectivity at around $300, best suited to budget-focused beginners rather than serious trainees.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Joroto M35 Magnetic Review

A quiet, compact budget magnetic rower with vertical storage and a 300 lb capacity, but a bare-bones monitor and no app connectivity.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Velocity Exercise CHR-2001 Programmable Magnetic Rower Review

A quiet, foldable mid-range magnetic rower with programmable resistance and heart-rate training, held back by no app support and a short parts warranty.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Kettler R220 Review

A quiet, folding magnetic rower with motorized 16-level resistance and 18 programs, but no app support and a rail that's cramped for taller users.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

Stamina DT397 Review

A compact, affordable dual air-and-magnetic rower with a livelier stroke than basic magnetic models, but a bare-bones monitor and light frame.

Read Article

Water rower

Sunny Obsidian Surge Review

A budget water rower offering smooth dynamic resistance and upright storage, held back by a basic console and short parts warranty.

Read Article

Water rower

XTERRA Fitness ERG600W Review

A well-built, affordable water rower with a smooth, quiet stroke, but only a basic monitor and no app or Bluetooth connectivity.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Circuit Fitness Deluxe Foldable Magnetic Rowing Machine (AMZ-986RW) Review

A quiet, foldable mid-budget magnetic rower with 8 resistance levels and a basic LCD, best for casual home cardio rather than connected training.

Read Article

Water rower

Fitness Reality 5000X Review

A mid-priced vertical-tank water rower with Bluetooth and MyCloudFitness app support that delivers a smooth pull and small footprint.

Read Article

Magnetic rower

Merach Q1S Review

A quiet, compact magnetic rower that delivers strong value for casual home cardio, with manual resistance limiting harder training.

Read Article

Air + magnetic rower

Sunny Health & Fitness Elite Wave (Hydro + Dual Resistance, SF-RW522017) Review

A hybrid water-plus-magnetic rower with 16 resistance levels, a full-metric console and app support, let down by a short parts warranty.

Read Article

Review

MaxKare Water Rowing Machine Review

Water resistance at a budget-friendly price. How this sub-$500 machine holds up against premium brands like WaterRower and First Degree.

Read Article